All American Tree Care vs Timberline Tree & Landscape: which to pick for tree removal?
Both companies show up as genuine five-star options for tree removal in Westchester County, and both come out near the top of our methodology. The real decision comes down to who's running the job on site and how fast you need a crew there, especially for storm or hazard work.
Side by side
- Google rating
- All American Tree Care: 5 (169 reviews)
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: 5 (222 reviews)
- Services
- All American Tree Care: tree removal, tree trimming pruning, stump grinding removal, arborist tree health
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: tree removal, stump grinding removal, arborist tree health, tree trimming pruning
- Best for
- All American Tree Care: Straightforward removals where you want the owner on site from quote to cleanup
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: Removals involving storm damage, hazard trees, or trees near structures needing arborist judgment
- Crew consistency
- All American Tree Care: Same named crew members (Jose, a 20-plus-year employee) return job after job
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: Multiple named crew (Ben, Domingo, Jon) support John, described as fast and thorough but less centered on one long-tenured team
- Verification
- All American Tree Care: Google-verified
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: Google-verified
- Composite score
- All American Tree Care: 93
- Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
All American Tree Care
Tim and his crew handle complex removals with visible care: they arrive on time, explain every step, work around electrical lines and delicate structures without mishap, and leave yards spotless. Reviewers repeatedly note his fairness on price, his hands-on involvement from quote through job completion, and a stable team that stays together-one foreman named Jose noted as long-tenured, and another worker cited as 20-plus years with the company.
Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc.
Five-star reviews across 222 assessments show a company that earns repeat business. Customers consistently praise John and his crew for transparent pricing, rapid turnarounds (sometimes same-day), and meticulous site cleanup. Storm damage calls receive next-day response, hazardous removals happen safely in tight spaces, and crew members go unprompted to help (tarping damaged homes, explaining trimming choices, grinding stumps efficiently). Arborist consultation stands out: John diagnoses overcrowded yards and recommends selective removal to save valuable specimens, with the same attention to detail that characterizes their stump grinding and emergency work.
The business claims BBB A+ accreditation and certified arborists since 1978, operating across Westchester and Rockland counties plus northern New Jersey. Reviewers name John (often called an arborist), Ben, Domingo, and Jon; their experience removing ash, magnolias, and 80-foot hazards comes through in testimonials. Fair pricing and next-day scheduling appear in nearly every review, with no complaints about cost or wait times recorded.
Which should you pick?
Pick All American Tree Care if
- You want the owner personally quoting, supervising, and present for the entire job
- You value a small, stable crew that's worked together for years and knows the routine
- You're comparing prices and want a straightforward, transparent quote without extra diagnostic services
Pick Timberline Tree & Landscape Inc. if
- You've got storm damage or a hazard tree and need same-day or next-day response
- You want a certified arborist's opinion on which trees to save versus remove
- You're dealing with a complex or larger property and want a company with broader crew capacity and long-standing credentials
Verdict
Pick All American Tree Care if you want the owner directly involved in every step and a crew you can count on to be the same familiar faces each visit. Pick Timberline Tree & Landscape if speed matters, especially after a storm, or if you need an arborist's judgment on which trees are worth saving before anything comes down. Both carry strong sentiment and near-identical pricing praise, so the choice really rests on whether your job calls for hands-on ownership or arborist-backed urgency.
Need help deciding?
Tell us about your project and compare quotes from qualified tree service in Westchester County, NY.
Your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores follow our published method only and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company responds faster for emergency tree removal?
- Timberline is the one noted for same-day emergency response and next-day crew arrival on storm damage calls, a specific capability not mentioned in All American's data.
- Which business has a certified arborist on staff?
- Timberline's John is described as an arborist who diagnoses tree health and advises on selective removal, operating under credentials dating to 1978.
- Are both companies rated similarly by customers?
- Yes, both hold 5-star Google ratings with strongly positive sentiment, All American from 169 reviews and Timberline from 222 reviews.
- Which is better for a routine, single-tree removal?
- All American fits well here since Tim personally quotes and oversees the job with a consistent, long-tenured crew.