All American Tree Care vs SavATree: which fits your tree's health needs?
Both companies show up as genuine options for arborist and tree health work in Westchester County, but they win on different strengths. This comparison, built using our methodology, weighs owner-led attention against certified plant health expertise to help you pick the right fit for diagnosing or treating a sick or declining tree.
Side by side
- Google rating
- All American Tree Care: 5 (170 reviews)
- SavATree: 4.7 (200 reviews)
- Services
- All American Tree Care: stump grinding removal, arborist tree health, tree removal, land lot clearing
- SavATree: tree trimming pruning, arborist tree health, stump grinding removal, emergency storm tree service
- Best for
- All American Tree Care: Tree removal, storm cleanup, and jobs where hands-on owner supervision matters
- SavATree: Ongoing tree health programs: disease treatment, fertilization, pest management
- Specialization signal
- All American Tree Care: General tree care with emphasis on safety near utilities and structures
- SavATree: ISA certification and named arborists focused specifically on plant health
- Verification
- All American Tree Care: Google-verified
- SavATree: Google-verified
- Composite score
- All American Tree Care: 94
- SavATree: 89
What reviewers say
All American Tree Care
From the moment Tim arrives for a quote through final cleanup, reviewers consistently report fast turnarounds, transparent pricing that often undercuts competitors, and crew professionalism that protects neighboring properties and utilities. His team's respect for older or valuable trees, careful hand-pruning where machines might damage roots, and willingness to include extra work at no cost reflect an owner who treats long-term crew stability and tree health as core values.
Named staff (Jose, Logan, and a crew member with 20+ years tenure) appear across reviews spanning a decade, signaling strong retention. Whether tackling century-old oaks within feet of electrical lines, working around challenging geometry like front stairs, or responding to storm damage same-day, the work pattern shows careful planning and equipment investment.
SavATree
Over hundreds of five-star reviews, customers praise named staff like Jack and Lorianne for explaining disease treatments, fertilization, and pest control with real expertise. Customers report being treated with respect, seeing healthier trees after service, and experiencing efficiency paired with courtesy across multiple visits over years.
Which should you pick?
Pick All American Tree Care if
- You want the owner personally quoting and overseeing the job
- Your priority is a removal or complex job near power lines or structures done cleanly
- You value a long-tenured, stable crew over a larger corporate bench
Pick SavATree if
- You need an ISA-certified arborist to diagnose disease, pests, or nutrient issues
- You want an ongoing health program (fertilization, treatment plans) tracked over years
- You prefer a longer-established company with a deeper bench of named specialists
Verdict
If the job is actually diagnosing or treating a tree's health, SavATree's ISA-certified arborists and track record of documented healthier outcomes make it the more direct fit, even though its composite score and rating trail All American's. If your need is broader, including removal, pruning, or storm-damage work where you want the owner personally involved from quote to cleanup, All American Tree Care's near-perfect rating and hands-on model are hard to beat.
Need help deciding?
Tell us about your project and compare quotes from qualified tree service in Westchester County, NY.
Enquiries submitted through our quote and contact forms may be passed to partner providers, and we may earn a referral fee from those introductions. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which business is better for a sick or dying tree?
- SavATree is the stronger fit, since its praise centers on ISA-certified arborists diagnosing disease, pests, and nutrient issues and delivering measurable health improvements.
- Which business has the higher rating?
- All American Tree Care has a 5.0 rating from 169 reviews, compared to SavATree's 4.7 from 200 reviews.
- Is All American Tree Care a good choice for tree health programs?
- It can handle general tree care well, but its reviews focus on removals, pricing, and cleanup rather than ongoing health assessment or disease treatment, which is SavATree's specialty.
- How long has SavATree been in business?
- SavATree has 40 years in business, according to its listed pros and usp.