All American Tree Care vs Owens Bros. Tree Service for tree planting & transplanting
Both companies are well-reviewed Westchester tree services, but planting and transplanting calls for a different skill set than storm cleanup or removal: careful root ball handling, correct depth and siting, and soil knowledge rather than speed or emergency response. Here's how All American Tree Care and Owens Bros. Tree Service stack up on that specific job, based on our methodology.
The differences that matter
- Owner involvement on every job. All American Tree Care has Tim personally quoting and supervising each job, which matters for transplanting where siting decisions and root handling need one accountable set of eyes, while Owens Bros. runs on a longer-tenured crew system under Dennis without that same single-point oversight mentioned.
- Crew stability vs. institutional experience. All American Tree Care's reviewers point to a stable, long-tenured crew (one foreman cited for years of service, another for 20-plus years), which supports consistent technique on delicate plantings, whereas Owens Bros. leans on 68 years of company history and neighborhood familiarity rather than named crew continuity.
- Sentiment and complaint history. All American Tree Care posts a higher sentiment sub-score (0.81 vs 0.73) with no complaints noted, while Owens Bros. has a documented scheduling slip and a technician attitude issue that, while minor, is the kind of friction that matters when a homeowner is trusting someone with a new or relocated tree.
- Storm and emergency strength doesn't apply here. Owens Bros.'s standout differentiators, 24/7 emergency response and rapid storm work, are largely irrelevant to planting and transplanting, whereas All American's cited strengths (careful work around structures and utilities, spotless cleanup) translate more directly.
Side by side
- Google rating
- All American Tree Care: 5 (170 reviews)
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: 4.9 (186 reviews)
- Services
- All American Tree Care: stump grinding removal, arborist tree health, tree removal, land lot clearing
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: tree removal, land lot clearing, emergency storm tree service, tree trimming pruning
- Best fit for planting/transplant precision
- All American Tree Care: Strong fit: owner-supervised, careful around obstacles, methodical crew
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: Adequate fit: capable crew but reputation built more on removal and storm work
- Pricing transparency
- All American Tree Care: Reviewers cite fair, transparent estimates directly from the owner
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: Described as fair compared to competitors, with honest advice and no upselling
- Verification
- All American Tree Care: Google-verified
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: Google-verified
- Composite score
- All American Tree Care: 94
- Owens Bros. Tree Service: 89
What reviewers say
All American Tree Care
From the moment Tim arrives for a quote through final cleanup, reviewers consistently report fast turnarounds, transparent pricing that often undercuts competitors, and crew professionalism that protects neighboring properties and utilities. His team's respect for older or valuable trees, careful hand-pruning where machines might damage roots, and willingness to include extra work at no cost reflect an owner who treats long-term crew stability and tree health as core values.
Named staff (Jose, Logan, and a crew member with 20+ years tenure) appear across reviews spanning a decade, signaling strong retention. Whether tackling century-old oaks within feet of electrical lines, working around challenging geometry like front stairs, or responding to storm damage same-day, the work pattern shows careful planning and equipment investment.
Owens Bros. Tree Service
Denis and his team deliver efficient, skilled work across tree removal, pruning, and stump removal in tight Manhattan spaces. Reviewers consistently praise honest estimates, careful cleanup, and same-day emergency response. One notable complaint involved a scheduling error and dismissive technician behavior on Easter Sunday; otherwise, the 4.9 rating reflects strong reliability and communication.
Which should you pick?
Pick All American Tree Care if
- You want the owner personally involved in siting and supervising a new planting or transplant
- You value a long-tenured, consistent crew handling delicate root work
- You want the highest sentiment score and a clean complaint record
Pick Owens Bros. Tree Service if
- You're weighing a planting job alongside broader tree care needs like storm cleanup or emergency removal
- You want a company with a long regional track record (68 years) and neighborhood familiarity
- You're comfortable with a minor, isolated scheduling or attitude complaint in an otherwise strong record
Verdict
For tree planting and transplanting specifically, All American Tree Care is the better fit. The job rewards hands-on oversight and careful, consistent technique over emergency-response muscle, and that's exactly where Tim's personal involvement and stable crew stand out. Owens Bros. remains a strong choice if you also need storm or emergency capability, but for a planting-focused project, the owner-led, detail-oriented approach at All American edges it out.
Need help deciding?
Tell us about your project and compare quotes from qualified tree service in Westchester County, NY.
Enquiries submitted through our quote and contact forms may be passed to partner providers, and we may earn a referral fee from those introductions. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Does Owens Bros.' 68 years in business mean more transplanting experience?
- Not necessarily. Their reputation and praise center on removal, pruning, and emergency storm work rather than planting or transplanting specifically.
- Which business has better cleanup after a planting job?
- Both are praised for thorough cleanup, but All American Tree Care's reviews describe consistently spotless results tied to the same long-tenured crew each time.
- Is price a deciding factor between the two?
- No. Both are described as fair and transparent on pricing, so the decision comes down to crew consistency and owner oversight rather than cost.