All American Tree Care vs O'Brother Tree Service LLC: which is better for tree trimming & pruning?

Updated 2026-10-20 · 2,974 reviewed · 129 listed · How we rank ›

Both of these crews show up as genuine options if you're getting a tree trimmed or pruned rather than removed outright, and both score well by our methodology. The real question for a pruning job is who works closer to the level of surgical care that fine trimming demands versus who's optimized for volume and speed, since those are different skills even though both companies do both types of work.

Side by side

Criterion	All American Tree Care	O'Brother Tree Service LLC
Google rating	4.9 (177 reviews)	4.8 (304 reviews)
Services	tree removal, tree trimming pruning, emergency storm tree service, stump grinding removal	arborist tree health, land lot clearing, tree removal, stump grinding removal
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	90	87

Google rating: All American Tree Care: 4.9 (177 reviews); O'Brother Tree Service LLC: 4.8 (304 reviews)
Services: All American Tree Care: tree removal, tree trimming pruning, emergency storm tree service, stump grinding removal; O'Brother Tree Service LLC: arborist tree health, land lot clearing, tree removal, stump grinding removal
Verification: All American Tree Care: Google-verified; O'Brother Tree Service LLC: Google-verified
Composite score: All American Tree Care: 90; O'Brother Tree Service LLC: 87

Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.

What reviewers say

All American Tree Care

Customers say the owner, Tim, answers calls quickly and often visits in person to quote. Crews show up on time, work efficiently, and leave yards clean. Reviewers point to fair prices and steady, professional work across removals and pruning.

Storm response stands out. One reviewer had a fallen tree on their house and car, and the crew arrived the next day and cleared it. Other reviewers praise careful work on an old Japanese maple and hand pruning.

O'Brother Tree Service LLC

Most reviewers say O'Brother arrives on time, works fast, and leaves the yard clean. Many call the pricing fair and say the staff stay polite and professional. Several repeat customers say they would hire the crew again.

Complaints centre on slow or missing replies before a job starts. Two reviewers describe unanswered calls, and one says a deposit was never refunded. A single one-star review calls the crew rude on site.

Verdict

For tree trimming and pruning specifically, the deciding factor is precision versus pace. All American Tree Care fits best when the job calls for careful, judgment-driven cuts near lines or structures and you want the owner and a stable crew involved start to finish. O'Brother Tree Service LLC fits best when you need reliable, fast-turnaround trimming backed by a bigger operation and responsive office coordination. Both carry strong reputations for cleanup and fair pricing, so the choice comes down to whether finesse or speed matters more for your trees.

Need help deciding?

Tell us about your project and compare quotes from qualified tree service in Westchester County, NY.

Quote and contact requests you submit through our forms may be passed to one or more partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a fee for those referrals. Rankings and scores are not influenced by referral fees and remain separate from our independent, published scoring.